I'll provide compact rated lists (1â10) for each protection type. Scale: 1 = very poor, 10 = excellent. Ratings assume typical shirt-weight constructions; actual performance depends on thickness, treatments, and certification. Fire-resistant 1. Aramid (Nomex/Kevlar blends) â 10 2. PBI â 10 3. Carbon fiber fabric â 9 4. Basalt fiber â 9 5. Fiberglass fabric â 9 6. Aluminized fabric (outer reflective) â 8.5 7. Modacrylic â 8 8. TMF / Technical FR blends â 8 9. FR-treated cotton â 7 10. FR polyester (engineered) â 6.5 11. Leather â 6.5 12. Wool â 6.5 13. Ripstop (cotton, treated) â 6 14. Denim â 5.5 15. Cotton â 4.5 16. Silk â 3.5 17. Polyester (regular) â 3 18. Nylon (regular) â 2.5 Waterproof (resistance to liquid penetration; breathability varies) 1. Laminated ePTFE (Gore-Tex) â 10 2. PU-coated nylon/polyester (seam-sealed) â 9.5 3. PVC-coated fabric â 9 4. Silicone-coated nylon â 8.5 5. Waxed cotton â 7 6. Nylon with DWR only â 6 7. Polyester with DWR â 6 8. Ripstop nylon (untreated) â 5 9. Denim â 3.5 10. Cotton â 2.5 11. Silk â 2 12. Leather (untreated) â 4 (repels some water but soaks eventually) Stab-resistant (cut/stab resistance; depends on layering and inserts) 1. Kevlar/aramid woven layers â 9 2. UHMWPE (Dyneema/Spectra) â 9 3. Chainmail/metal mesh â 9.5 (heavy) 4. Steel/ceramic plate inserts â 10 (localized) 5. High-density polyethylene composites â 8.5 6. Leather (thick, treated) â 5.5 7. Denim (heavy layered) â 4.5 8. Cotton â 2.5 9. Silk â 2 10. Polyester/nylon Voir plus